We got to try out the Lamb Bark and the Super Gravy. The chew was the texture of a rice cake, which Madden LOVED and absolutely devoured. The gravy, however, liquefied his guts, which was unfortunate because he liked it a lot. We tried several times over a week or two to integrate it without any luck. Pitbulls are notorious for being super sensitive though, so it's probably him and not the products. Easy to make, inexpensive, and good quality ingredients. Overall a good product. Just not something we can repurchase due to his apparent sensitivities.