We signed a contract with Encore Concrete Coatings for a single-color Stargazer flake coating with a lifetime warranty on May 22, 2023.
When the install took place in SEP 2023, it was almost immediately defective. Additionally, Encore used 2 different colors instead of the contracted single color, & visible flaws appeared across the deck within days. Within months, the coating began chipping and failing, the very problem we had specifically raised and Encore had dismissed.
Over the next 19 months (SEP 23–MAY 25), we contacted Encore at least 14 documented times to report issues, share photos, and request repairs.
Encore’s own reps inspected the site & acknowledged the work was below their standards. Yet the company repeatedly delayed action, offered inadequate fixes, & shifted explanations—from initially admitting a surface-preparation failure to later, more than a year after our first complaint, blaming “moisture” & claiming a “moisture barrier” was needed. Moreover, on SEP 2, 2025 after being served in Iowa Small Claims Court, the Encore COO stated, “I have been doing this a long time & I can easily tell from these photos this is a prep issue, not moisture”.
Until our Better Business Bureau filing, every contact & inspection had characterized the issue as a workmanship or prep failure, never a moisture problem. Assessment: this company uses the "moisture barrier" clause in their contract as a catch all to come and redo work at an additional charge to the customer.
Over the course of 2 years, we made more than a dozen documented attempts to secure proper completion through direct outreach, the Better Business Bureau, & the Illinois Attorney General (Encore failed to respond after 2 inquiries), before finally filing in Iowa Small Claims Court.
On OCT 9, 2025, Encore Concrete Coatings was found in civil court as negligent in installing the pool deck floor coating. Iowa case number is SCSC751203 and can be looked up on Iowa Courts Online.
Also, please make sure to check the BBB reviews and not just blindly trust Google reviews. BBB reviews tell an entirely different story about this company.